I think almost everybody that gets seriously into science is driven by curiosity. Love the organization and connection between the claim, reason, and evidence. After gathering evidence and deciding on a central claim, students learn how to plan their arguments and begin drafting. Developing evidencebased arguments from texts readwritethink. Provide or have students create a graphic organizer with 3 columns. The data needs to be appropriate and sufficient to support the claim. Claim, evidence and interpretation cei pdf 4 kb character analysis pdf. While both sides make an acceptable case, the letter provides a bettersupported argument. Many students choose to complete a few different graphic organizers based on a few different topics so they a variety and can eventually narrow it down to one to take through the writing process.
Claim evidence detailed body of evidence or reasons that support answer include enough details to answer the question. The perfect spanish graphic organizer to help students construct a variety of essays, this product clearly illustrates the connections between the claim, reasons, and evidence allowing students to better organize their thinking for persuasive, argumentative, and informative essays. See supporting evidencebased claims graphic organizer for teacher reference as an example. Articles from units written answer or highlightunderline evidence maps, charts, etc id and circle or write answer notes of evidence from a video there is an example on the next page. Perfect for argument essay planning in the bilingual, ell, or spanishlanguage classroom. In unit 1, students formed evidencebased claims after collecting evidence. Based on scientific principles each piece of evidence may have a different justification for why it supports the. Page cause and effect graphic organizer 1 comparecontrast graphic organizer 2 concept definition map graphic organizer 3 drawing conclusions graphic organizer 4 identifying authors purpose graphic organizer 5 main idea and supporting details graphic organizer 6 making inferences graphic. In an interview with students, mits kerry emmanuel said, at the end of the day, its just raw curiosity. Additionally, in persuasion, the claim usually comes first. In this lesson, students plan the introductory and concluding paragraphs of their end of unit assessment. Odell education is dedicated to fostering creativity and critical thinking. Students expand their ability into organizing evidence to develop and explain claims through a close reading of the text. There is space for three reasons and subsequent evidences in support of these reasons.
Lincs evidencebased instruction and teacher induction4 that these practices are effective, and the competencies provide a road map for how to apply and implement evidencebased instruction in the classroom. The students explanation or answer, as you may have guessed, will consist of three parts. Develop claim s and counterclaims fairly, supplying the most relevant data and. The examples provided in the teacher versions are possibilities meant more to illustrate the process than to shape textual analysis.
Evidence based argument builds the case for its claim out of available evidence. The next part of the evidence based claims unit is organizing evidence based claims. I claim that the relationship between the salt and the water is that they weigh the same before and after mixing. This graphic organizer is adapted in collaboration with odell education based on their forming evidence based claims worksheet also see. Claim evidence reasoning cer writing graphic organizer. This organization is designed to strengthen the precision of instruction and assessment, as well as. Making evidencebased claims units ccss ela literacy. The teacher introduces and models writing evidencebased claims. Graphic organizers can help students organize their thinking and connect new information to prior knowledge. Strategies for teaching argumentative writing integrating reading and writing. Ask students to clarify what makes this kind of text an argument as opposed to persuasion. Evidence provide scientific data to support your claim. We are going to practice this skill of making evidence based claims that are based in the words, sentences, and ideas of a text by closely reading and analyzing text.
The organizing evidencebased claims worksheet allows for an expanded claim that includes two points, and then the two points are separated out so that evidence may be given in support of each point. Sep 25, 2012 the claim, evidence, reasoning framework is a scaffolded way to teach the scientific method. Again, teacher will need to project the graphic organizer. Graphic organizers evidencebased intervention network. Project, for example, this essay on gertrude in hamlet and ask students to identify the claim, reasons, and evidence. Forming evidence based claims graphic organizer one new blank one the same as from lesson 15, plus one for display. A statement that answers your question scientific data that support the claim data need to be appropriate pictures, graphs, table observation reasoning how your evidence justifies your claim. Common core teaching and learning strategies ela grades 612. Accountable talk ii the accountable talk toolkit provides resources for implementation, including what it looks like in the classroom, lesson examples, and scaffolds. This would prepare them to participate in the lesson. Supporting claims with evidence the curriculum corner 123. Keep in mind that a wellsubstantiated claim may later become evidence or reasoning for another claim. Bob should be elected class president because hes a natural leader. Students independently read part of the text with a textdependent question to guide them.
Fill out the making evidence based claims lesson worksheet about steve jobs. Students follow along as they listen to part of the text read aloud and discuss a series of text. Students can use this worksheet for persuasive or informative essay planning. Based on x, people assumed y, which made sense at the time, but now we. Model graphic organizer for the argumentative essay. Parts 12 focus on making evidence based claims as readers. The organizing evidence based claims worksheet allows for an expanded claim that includes two points, and then the two. Longterm targets addressed based on nysp12 ela ccls i can cite several pieces of text based evidence to support an analysis of literary text. The process involves the ways that students collaborate with peers. The perfect graphic organizer to help students construct a variety of essays, this product clearly illustrates the connections between the claim, reasons, and evidence allowing students to better organize their thinking for persuasive, argumentative, and informative essays. Parts 12 focus on making evidencebased claims as readers. Forming evidence based claims binders full of evidence. This question is based on a phenomena or lab experience.
Solid understanding of the material at hand, therefore, is necessary in order to argue effectively. Parts 4 and 5 focus on expressing evidence based claims in writing. Students could work in a support class, with time to highlight and discuss portions of their notes that could be used effectively. Make sure all details support the claim and are not offtopic. Once students have practiced the concept of supporting a claim with evidence, you can use our graphic organizer for independent work. Does not provide evidence, or only provides inappropriate evidence evidence that does not support the claim. Place at a center along with topic ideas and have students work to write evidence for a claim. Multiple copies can be printed to help students organize multiple reasonings and evidences for their essays. Based on scientific principles each piece of evidence may have a different justification for. See supporting evidence based claims graphic organizer for. They provide visual representation for students to take notes on new mathematical concepts they are learning. For each chapter, there will be students forming evidence based claims about two of the following aspects of the narrative one from column 1 and one from column 2.
Longterm targets addressed based on nysp12 ela ccls i can cite several pieces of textbased evidence to support an analysis of literary text. Fill out the making evidence based claims lesson worksheet about the second part of steve jobs speech. At the heart of these skills lies students ability to make and evaluate claims based on various types of evidence and on their understanding of key ideas and concepts within various science disciplines. Restatement of question in own words unpack it claim evidence detailed body of evidence or reasons that support answer include enough details to answer the question. Explain that they are going to look at how the author uses evidence to support the first reason. Provides appropriate, but insufficient evidence to support claim. Model graphic organizer for the argumentative essay support your claim refute the objections ask the questions express your viewpoint evidence main point 1 evidence details main point 2 evidence details main point 3 evidence details main point 1 evidence details main point 2 evidence details main point 3 evidence. A graphic organizer is a tool used to facilitate student understanding of new mathematical concepts. The purpose of this graphic organizer is to help make connections between the claim, the evidence of that claim, and the reason that the evidence supports that claim. Then, using text evidence for support, state your argument claim. Cer all starts with a question asked by the teacher.
Or, use as a writing option during independent writing time in your classroom. The following graphic organizer shows different types of evidence that was used in passage 2 letter to the editor example of types of evidence claim. Graphic organizer for claim, evidence, reasoning graphic. Great graphic organizer showing the connection between claim, reason, and evidence. You may also want them to interact with the documents by writing questions, defining terms, or adding information. While students are working, i will walk around and help where needed. A claim should be supported with specific evidence not just by opinions.
Claim, evidence, reasoning graphic organizer parents as. I only complete one example of leadership as a factor that helped salva survive in a long walk to water. Reading skills development students are introduced to the lesson focus on making evidencebased claims about texts. As i looked over this particular worksheet, i noticed a similarity to work that i have done previously when we worked on the research papers. Oct 23, 2017 in this video, i model how to complete the forming evidence based claims graphic organizer. Citing text evidence rubric waunakee intermediate school. Claim, reason, and evidence graphic organizer graphic. Students use a forming evidence based claims graphic organizer similar to ones they used in module 1. Claims evidence reasoning what do you know or claim. You can use this claim, evidence, reasoning graphic organizer for many subjects. After having filled in these forming evidence based claims graphic organizers, students receive a new essay. Claim evidence reasoning c er writing graphic organizer remember. When students have written in the claim, reasons, and counterclaim, turn their attention to the boxes under reason 1. Teaching argumentation and reading for evidence with online.
Teachers in all science classrooms can apply writing tasks designed around the. The structure includes the cer framework of a claim, evidence and reasoning. I claim that we can make a solution by combining salt and water. The toolkit entries come from a variety of sources, e. This is like the thesis statements we created during the research project. Also available in english claim evidence reasoning template pdf ten. Students will write an explanation for each piece of evidence which draws connections between the evidence and the outside world or between the evidence and other evidence in the text ri.
Claim, evidence and reasoning rubric 24 alpha boxes 25. He believes that remembering the holocaust in a public way will actually encourage people and political leaders to treat others with unfairness and hostility. Gathering and analyzing evidence use these strategies. Part iii organizing evidencebased claims the next part of the evidencebased claims unit is organizing evidencebased claims. Claims reasons evidence mason county middle school. Organizing evidence based claims binders full of evidence. Reasons or evidence to support your claim all evidence you present in this section should support your position. Is there enough of the right kind of evidence to support the claim. Making a claim i state a conclusion that i have come to and can support with evidence from the text after. This graphic organizer is adapted in collaboration with odell education based on their forming evidence based claims worksheet also see standalone document on and. Evidence organizer using the handouts, find the evidence that connects each claim to the reasoning, and add it to the table. Our approaches equip students with the literacy essential for success in college, career and civic life. Lastly, students will write their evidence based claim w.
Students read and annotate a pdf version of the text by. This is an option if they only already have an idea that they would like to work on. You can use this claim, evidence, reasoning graphic organizer for. This graphic organizer can be used for writing persuasive opinion essays or any essayparagraph in which the author defends a claim using text evidence. Evidence comes from sources, fieldwork, and research. Reasoning explain why your evidence supports your claim.
Jcps analytical and applied science advantages of science notebooks advantages for students science notebooks are a learning tool for students to record their thinking and learning. Claim evidence reasoning template pdf ten lessons ive learned from claim evidence reasoning template pdf claim evidence reasoning template pdf claim, evidence, reasoning graphic organizer a great form to guide a parentteacher conference. Justify the claims using evidence and reasoning in the middle and high school classrooms using our claim evidence reasoning templates. The cer examples are based on two commercials and one data table. The teacher should model selecting both examples of evidence that are based on the text and examples of evidence that are not based on evidence as a caution, and then model rejecting evidence that. While both sides make an acceptable case, representative walls provides a stronger argument for the road construction. For type of evidence, fill in whether it is from anatomy a, embryological development e, fossils. In pairs, students make an evidencebased claim of their own and present it to the class. Part 3 focuses on preparing to express evidence based claims by organizing evidence and thinking. Apr 18, 20 forming evidence based claims for frankenstein, chapters. Describe what an adaptation is and why your evidence allowed you to determine the beak was the best adaptation. In order to build their knowledge on the argument topic and practice the skill of gathering evidence to support claims, students read and analyze four articles that discuss the effects of digital media usage. Does the fossil evidence support or refute the claim that cetaceans evolved through change over time from an ancestral mammal that lived on land. Each pair of rows will have one of the three chapters.
Great spanish graphic organizer showing the logical relationship between claims, reasons, and evidences. Claim evidence reasoning cer student graphic organizer question. The essay map is an interactive graphic organizer that enables students to. Which group of modernday land mammals has ankle bones that are most similar to those of the.
1221 196 925 1091 303 8 986 1395 645 194 815 579 757 464 831 1432 1213 121 1336 154 90 879 651 1474 163 730 531 1009 237 1016 225 1062